Home > Cadillac XT4 vs BMW X1
Small SUVs can still bring big luxury, and the new Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 are prime examples. Both elevate your driving experience with fine-tuned engines and performance-ready specs, but only the Cadillac model gives you top-shelf safety features, weekend-worthy towing, and a more competitive MSRP than many other vehicles in its segment – including the BMW X1.
Take a leisurely cruise through the 2024 updates to the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 to see how the Cadillac trims show up and show out in every category, then visit our dealership for a luxurious test drive!
Comparing Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 trim levels means asking yourself if you enjoy the freedom of choice. The redesigned new Cadillac XT4 is available in three stunning trims: Luxury, Premium Luxury, and Sport. Its chiseled, streamlined exterior comes in eight on-trend metallic hues, and all three levels come with incredible standard features like an HD Rear Vision Camera, Cadillac Connected Access, and Remote Start.
A sprawling 33-inch infotainment interface seamlessly integrates into the dash, and cabin technology abounds with wireless Apple CarPlay®, Android Auto™, SiriusXM®, and Wi-Fi hotspot capability. Seats are upscale and comfortable with Inteluxe or leather upholstery and power adjustment. Available features include wireless charging, an AKG® 14-speaker audio system, front lumbar massage, heated front and rear seats and steering wheel, and a Head-Up Display.
The BMW X1 is only available in one trim, called the BMW X1 xDrive28i, and two included colors, Alpine White or Jet Black. Veganza upholstery gives the cabin a sporty feel but lacks the sumptuous luxury feel of the Cadillac interior. The SensaTec-covered dash has a 10.7-inch touch screen that gives you access to Apple CarPlay®, Android Auto™, and SiriusXM®. Adjust the multicolor ambient light system to customize the cabin mood.
If you’d like to purchase additional packages, you can access a panoramic moonroof, wireless device charging, a Head-Up Display, an Auto-Dimming Rearview Mirror, Video Augmented Reality for Navigation, and a Harman Kardon® Surround Sound System.
The Cadillac XT4 delivers efficient performance with a 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder engine and smooth-shifting nine-speed auto transmission with manual-feel paddle shifters. Its confident exterior styling mirrors its muscular 258 pound-feet of torque, and its braking system is decisive and firm. Top it all off with a 3,500-pound towing capacity,1 and you’ve got one superior Cadillac SUV!
With near-identical city fuel economy, the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 make compelling commuter vehicles. Both SUVs are powered by synthetic oil for top-level performance, but only the Cadillac model has an Oil-Life Monitoring System for easy level checks.
The all-wheel-drive BMW X1 is not rated for towing. While its 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder and seven-speed automatic transmission work together to generate a slightly higher 295 pound-feet of torque, its real-world acceleration doesn’t feel as exciting as you’d expect.
| 2024 Cadillac XT4 | 2024 BMW X1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 2.0L Turbo 4-Cyl w/Auto Start-Stop | 2.0L Turbo 4-Cyl w/Auto Start-Stop |
| Horsepower | 235 | 241 |
| Torque | 258 lb-ft | 295 lb-ft |
| Transmission | 9-Speed Automatic | 7-Speed Dual-Clutch Automatic |
| Drivetrain | FWD or AWD | AWD |
| Towing Capacity | 3,500 lbs1 | Not Rated |
| EPA-Est. MPG (City/Hwy) | 24/29 MPG2 – FWD 23/28 MPG2 – AWD |
25/34 MPG3 |
| Trim Levels | 3 | 1 |
| Interior Features | Inteluxe & Leather upholstery 33-in Curved Infotainment & Instrument display |
Leather upholstery 10.7-in Infotainment display 10.25-in Instrument display |
| Safety Features |
Rear Park Assist Safety Alert Seat Passenger Sensing System Forward Collision Alert Teen Driver |
Parking Assist Backup Assist Rearview Camera Active Park Distance Control Front & Rear Head Protection System |
| Available Drive Modes | Tour, Snow/Ice, Sport, Off-Road, AWD | Sport, Efficient, Personal |
The Cadillac XT4 is a slightly longer SUV, measuring 180.9 inches compared to the BMW model’s 177.2 inches. The Cadillac XT4 is also more than 4 inches wider than the BMW X1, which translates to additional front shoulder space.
The difference between Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 head space is minimal, with the BMW SUV offering roughly 2 extra inches of front headroom. The real difference is noticeable in the backseat, where the Cadillac XT4 delivers an extra 2.5 inches of legroom compared to the BMW X1. This legroom is critical for positioning car seats and giving backseat teens plenty of space to stretch out.
The XT4 even outperforms other top competitors in cabin space, as evidenced in this Cadillac XT4 vs. Lincoln Corsair comparison. The bottom line? Choose a Cadillac SUV for maximum cabin relaxation!
Along with its expanded legroom dimensions, the new Cadillac XT4 also provides a higher driving position, so you’ll gain a more elevated view of your surroundings. Its standard trunk can hold up to 22.5 cubic feet of gear and groceries, nearly identical to the BMW X1 trunk space of 25.6 cubic feet.
| 2024 Cadillac XT4 | 2024 BMW X1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Exterior Length | 181.1 in | 177.2 in |
| Exterior Width | 76.7 in | 72.6 in |
| Exterior Height | 64.1 in (w/roof rails) | 64.6 in |
| Front/Rear Headroom | 39.4 / 38.3 in | 42.1 / 39.3 in |
| Front/Rear Legroom | TBD / 39.5 in | 40.4 / 37 in |
| Passenger Seating | 5 | 5 |
| Cargo Capacity (Standard/Max) | 22.5 / 48.9 cu ft | 25.67 / 46.88 cu ft |
When you want reliable performance, you need a vehicle that costs less to maintain, has zero reported issues, and is backed by a six-year unlimited mileage Roadside Assistance Program4 – in short, you need a 2024 Cadillac XT4. In the luxury SUV Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 comparison, the XT4 wins again.
According to repair experts, the new Cadillac SUV costs $76 less5 to maintain than the average luxury vehicle, while the BMW X1 costs $56 more.6 Over the course of multiple years, even decades, of ownership, these elevated BMW maintenance costs add up to less savings and more headaches for you.
In a head-to-head 2024 Cadillac XT4 vs. 2024 BMW X1 safety systems comparison, there’s just no contest. The Cadillac XT4 blows the BMW X1 out of the water with its enhanced – yet standard on every trim – list of safety features, including a Safety Alert Seat system that pulses to help you identify potential crashes and a Passenger Sensing System that automatically adjusts airbags based on who’s in the vehicle.
Add an Active Safety Package to certain trims and gain Speed Limit Assist, Rear Pedestrian Alert, Traffic Sign Recognition, and more. The XT4 trims also feature a standard Tire Pressure Monitoring System and an Oil-Life Monitoring System, so you can keep tabs on the health and safety of your engine.
The BMW X1 safety systems are not nearly as well-rounded. This model comes with standard Active Park Distance Control, Parking Assistant, Backup Assistant, a rearview camera, and an airbag system, but you’ll need to purchase additional packages to gain Parking Assistance Plus and Surround View with 3D View.
Now that you’ve seen how the trims, specs, safety, and repair costs of the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 compared, are you ready to start your Cadillac SUV journey? Visit Bravo Cadillac El Paso to explore trims, experience the elegant power in person, and discuss Cadillac XT4 lease specials that can get you on the road and on your way with as many savings as possible!
According to RepairPal.com, the 2024 Cadillac XT4 averages an annual repair cost of $783.5 RepairPal.com reports that a 2024 BMW X1 costs an average of $915 to maintain annually. The average cost to maintain a luxury vehicle is $859,6 which means the Cadillac SUV costs less than average to maintain, while the BMW X1 will cost you more than other luxury models.
The new Cadillac XT4 has received top marks in all crash-test categories from the IIHS,7 whereas the new BMW X1 was given top marks in all IIHS categories but one: seat belt reminders.8 Based on the fact that the Cadillac XT4 has a much more comprehensive list of safety features, we believe the Cadillac SUV shows itself to be the safer choice for you and your family.
According to experts, a 2024 Cadillac XT4 will lose up to 40% of its original value after five years.9 In comparison, the resale value of a 2024 BMW X1 is estimated to depreciate up to 35% after five years.10 Ultimately, the resale value depends on how well you maintain your vehicle, so for maximum return on your investment, keep up with all regularly scheduled service appointments.
1This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://www.edmunds.com/cadillac/xt4/2024/st-401994018/features-specs/
2Based on EPA city/highway estimate 24/29 for FWD and 23/28 for AWD and fuel tank capacity. Your range may be less.
3Preliminary EPA-estimated figures are for comparison purposes only. Your actual mileage will vary, depending on speed, driving habits, trip length and driving conditions; actual mileage may be lower. Note for MPGe: All data are provisional and subject to official confirmation. The provisional power consumption figures have been calculated based on the ECE test cycle.
4Warranties listed on this web page shall not be solely relied upon. Warranties may be subject to specific terms, restrictions, exclusions, and fees. Additional warranty information may be obtained by visiting the official website of the warranty provider. Contact our dealership for complete details.
5This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://repairpal.com/cadillac/xt4
6This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://repairpal.com/reliability/bmw/x1#:~:text=With%20Another%20Vehicle-,Cost,%24652%20for%20all%20vehicle%20models.&text=The%20average%20total%20annual%20cost%20for%20unscheduled%20repairs%20and%20maintenance,model%20years%20of%20a%20vehicle.
7Reference to this third-party claim is solely for informational purposes and not to be relied upon. For details regarding this award, visit https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/Cadillac/xt4-4-door-suv/2024
8Reference to this third-party claim is solely for informational purposes and not to be relied upon. For details regarding this award, visit https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/bmw/x1-4-door-suv/2024
9This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://caredge.com/cadillac/xt4/depreciation
10This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://caredge.com/bmw/x1/depreciation
