Home > New Cadillac XT4 > XT4 vs BMW X1
Small SUVs can still bring big luxury, and the new Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 are prime examples. Both elevate your driving experience with fine-tuned engines and performance-ready specs, but the Cadillac model gives you standard luxuries, a more competitive MSRP than many other vehicles in its segment – including the BMW X1 – and greater warranty coverage.
Take a leisurely cruise through the 2025 updates to the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 to see how the Cadillac trims show up in every category, then visit Bravo Cadillac in El Paso for a luxurious test drive!
The new 2025 Cadillac XT4 is available in two stunning trims: Premium Luxury and Sport. Its chiseled, streamlined exterior comes in eight on-trend metallic hues. However, it is often said that it’s what’s on the inside that counts. Both tiers come with incredible standard features like an HD Surround Vision Camera, Cadillac Connected Access, leather seating, and Remote Start.
A sprawling 33-inch infotainment interface seamlessly integrates into the dash, and cabin technology abounds with wireless Apple CarPlay® and Android Auto™ compatibility, three years of available SiriusXM®,2 and Wi-Fi hotspot capability. Notable upgrades include wireless charging, front seat lumbar massage functionality, heated front and rear seats and steering wheel, and a Head-Up Display.
Comparing Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 trim levels is fairly straightforward because the BMW model also has two trims: the BMW X1 xDrive28i and the BMW X1 M35i. Standard Veganza upholstery gives the cabin a sporty feel but lacks the sumptuous luxury of genuine leather. The SensaTec-covered dash has a 10.7-inch touch screen that gives you access to Apple CarPlay®, Android Auto™, and SiriusXM®. Adjust the multicolor ambient light system to customize the cabin mood.
Unlike the Cadillac XT4, where a premium audio system is standard, the 2025 BMW X1 has an available Harman Kardon® audio system on its higher trim level, with a standard HiFi sound system on the lower trim.
| 2025 Cadillac XT4 | 2025 BMW X1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 2.0L turbo 4-cyl | 2.0L turbo 4-cyl |
| Horsepower | 235 | 241 |
| Torque | 258 lb-ft | 295 lb-ft |
| Transmission | 9-speed automatic | 7-speed dual-clutch automatic |
| Drivetrain | FWD or AWD | AWD |
| Towing Capacity | 3,500 lbs | 3,499 lbs |
| EPA-Est. MPG (Cty / Hwy) | 24 / 29 MPG – FWD 23 / 28 MPG – AWD |
24 / 33 MPG |
| Trim Levels | 2 | 2 |
| Interior Features | Leather upholstery 33-in Curved Infotainment & Instrument display |
Veganza upholstery 10.7-in Infotainment display 10.25-in Instrument display |
| Safety Features | Adaptive Cruise Control Safety Alert Seat Traffic Sign Recognition HD Surround View Monitor Teen Driver |
Dynamic Cruise Control Servotronic Vehicle-Speed-Sensitive Power Steering Rearview Camera Active Park Distance Control |
| Available Drive Modes | Tour, Snow/Ice, Sport, Off-Road, AWD | Sport, Efficient, Personal |
The Cadillac XT4 delivers efficient performance with a 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder engine and smooth-shifting nine-speed auto transmission with manual-feel paddle shifters. Its confident exterior styling goes well with its muscular 258 pound-feet of torque, and its braking system is decisive and firm. To top it off, it has a 3,500-pound towing capacity,3 which means you can bring a Jet Ski, an enclosed U-Haul trailer, or even a 17-foot camper.
The all-wheel-drive BMW X1 can also tow nearly 3,500 pounds.4 While its 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder and seven-speed automatic transmission work together to generate a slightly higher 295 pound-feet of torque, you will need to add on the M Sport Package for paddle shifters.
| 2025 Cadillac XT4 | 2025 BMW X1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Exterior Length | 180.9 in | 177.2 in |
| Exterior Width | 76.7 in | 72.6 in |
| Exterior Height | 64.1 in | 64.6 in |
| Front / Rear Leg Room | 44.1 / 39.5 in | 40.4 / 37 in |
| Front / Rear Shoulder Room | 57 / 55.1 in | 56.1 / 55.1 in |
| Passenger Seating | 5 | 5 |
| Standard Cargo Capacity | 22.5 cu ft | 25.7 cu ft |
The new Cadillac XT4 is a slightly longer luxury compact SUV, measuring 180.9 inches compared to the BMW model’s 177.2 inches. The Cadillac XT4 is also more than four inches wider than the BMW X1.
Overall, your family will be more comfortable in the Cadillac model’s slightly roomier cabin. For example, the differences in Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1 legroom are significant. The driver will get four inches of additional space to stretch out, which is useful if you’re on the taller side. Meanwhile, the Cadillac XT4 delivers an extra 2.5 inches of rear legroom compared to the BMW X1. This supremacy is also apparent in our Cadillac XT4 vs. Lincoln Corsair comparison. In fact, the Cadillac model has best-in-class second-row legroom.7
After investing so much money in a vehicle, it’s important that you’re able to rely on it for the long term. Unfortunately, the 2025 BMW X1 has a consumer reliability rating of only 63/100,8 according to J.D. Power. By contrast, the 2025 Cadillac XT4 scores 12 points higher.9
Each of these automakers provides warranty coverage and Roadside Assistance to drivers as a testament to their confidence in their respective vehicles. However, while the BMW X1 comes with a four-year/50,000-mile Powertrain Warranty1 and four years of Roadside Assistance coverage,10 the Cadillac XT4 gives owners more – including six years/70,000 miles of Powertrain Coverage1 and the same amount of Roadside Assistance.10
The Cadillac XT4 aims to look after your loved ones by offering more than 20 standard driver-assistance features, including:
The Teen Driver program allows you to put the equivalent of parental controls on your vehicle so that music can’t be raised above a specific volume, for example. You can set a maximum speed, such as 85 mph, which can make it easier to hand over the keys to a newly licensed driver. You can also set a restriction so they can’t shift out of “Park” if their seatbelt isn’t buckled.
The BMW X1 also comes with compelling safety features, such as standard Forward Collision Mitigation, Automatic Blind Spot Detection, Park Distance Control, Parking Assistant, and a rearview camera. However, you’ll need to purchase additional packages to gain Parking Assistance Plus and Surround View with 3D View, and no equivalent to the Teen Driver technology is offered.
Now that you’ve seen how the trims, specs, and safety of the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 compare, are you ready to start your Cadillac SUV journey? Visit Bravo Cadillac of El Paso to explore trims, experience the elegant power of this SUV in person, and discuss Cadillac XT4 lease specials that can get you on the road and on your way with potentially more savings.
If you want to further your research, read about the Cadillac XT4 compared to the Lexus RX, or talk to our team directly about different SUVs you’re considering.
Although RepairPal.com does not have specific numbers for the Cadillac XT4, it ascertains that Cadillac models, on average, have an annual repair cost of $783.11 RepairPal.com also reports that a 2025 BMW X1 costs an average of $915 to maintain annually.12 The average cost to maintain a luxury vehicle is $859.60,12 which means the Cadillac SUV costs less, while the BMW X1 costs more.
When it comes to reliability, the Cadillac XT4 scores higher with J.D. Power. The Cadillac XT4 Quality & Reliability rating is 75 out of 100,9 compared to the BMW X1, which has a Quality & Reliability score of just 63 out of 100.8 Furthermore, the Cadillac SUV is backed by longer-lasting Powertrain Warranty coverage and Roadside Assistance.
According to J.D. Power, both the Cadillac XT4 and BMW X1 have a resale value of 79 out of 100,8, 9 which falls in the average range. However, how much you can get for this vehicle will likely depend on its condition at the time of sale. The Cadillac XT4 has a substantially higher Quality & Reliability score than the BMW X1 model.8, 9
1Warranties listed on this webpage shall not be solely relied upon. Warranties may be subject to specific terms, restrictions, exclusions, and fees. Additional warranty information may be obtained by visiting the official website of the warranty provider. Contact our dealership for complete details.
2SiriusXM Extended Service subscription will stop at the end of the applicable subscription period unless you decide to continue service. Plan is non-transferable and non-refundable. Service subject to the SiriusXM Customer Agreement and Privacy Policy, visit www.siriusxm.com/terms to see complete terms and how to cancel which includes online methods or calling 1-866-635-2349. Some services, content and features are subject to device capabilities, an active data connection enabled in the vehicle and location availability. All fees, content and features are subject to change. Content varies by subscription plan. SiriusXM and related logos are trademarks of Sirius XM Radio Inc. and its respective subsidiaries.
3Requires Heavy Duty Trailering Package. Before you buy a vehicle or use it for trailering, carefully review the trailering section of the Owner’s Manual. The weight of passengers, cargo and options or accessories may reduce the amount you can tow.
4When properly equipped.
5Based on EPA city/highway estimate 24/29 for FWD and 23/28 for AWD and fuel tank capacity. Your range may be less.
6Preliminary EPA-estimated figures are for comparison purposes only. Your actual mileage will vary, depending on speed, driving habits, trip length and driving conditions; actual mileage may be lower. Note for MPGe: All data are provisional and subject to official confirmation. The provisional power consumption figures have been calculated based on the ECE test cycle.
7For reference, see: https://www.cadillac.com/suvs/xt4#specs
8This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://www.jdpower.com/cars/2025/bmw/x1
9This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://www.jdpower.com/cars/2025/cadillac/xt4
10Roadside Assistance services provided by third-party providers for vehicles with an eligible service plan, subject to limitations and restrictions. Roadside Assistance is not a warranty; refer to the vehicle’s Owner’s Handbook for warranty details. Excludes costs for repairs, parts, labor, property loss, and expenses from accidents, abuse, racing, vandalism, and certain other conditions. Contact our dealership for details.
11This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://repairpal.com/cadillac/xt4
12This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://repairpal.com/reliability/bmw/x1#:~:text=With%20Another%20Vehicle-,Cost,%24652%20for%20all%20vehicle%20models.&text=The%20average%20total%20annual%20cost%20for%20unscheduled%20repairs%20and%20maintenance,model%20years%20of%20a%20vehicle.
